Metal Roof Vs Asphalt Shingle Reddit

I ran into a roof that would have been totaled had it been an asphalt shingle but instead was just an ugly dented metal roof.

Metal roof vs asphalt shingle reddit.

Regardless there are numerous ways to reduce noise with either type of roof. Every year billions of pounds of asphalt end up in our landfills. I ve gone through a lot of old posts and i still would like to hear some current pros vs. A metal roof on a home is different from the bare tin roofing of a barn or event center and is much quieter.

Knew the roof needed replacing when i bought the house 2 years ago ready to pull the trigger this year. But if you look at the bigger picture metal is the obvious choice. One thing to worry about from my experience limited with metal is the appearance of your roof if it gets hailed on again. Asphalt shingle roofing is a dominant material for residences.

Compared to an asphalt roof on a 1 200 square foot single story home costing 4 200 to 8 500 metal roofs cost 8 400 to 19 000. Metal roofs generally can run from 120 to 900 per 100 square feet one 10 foot by 10 foot area or a square of material while asphalt shingles will be between 100 and 200 per 100 square. My home is about 1620 sf and was built in the 1940 s. Installation installing asphalt shingles is easier to do than installing a metal roof but due to the weight of shingles especially the traditional ones the previous shingle materials may need to be removed first.

However metal roofing is surging in popularity as more aesthetic options become available. Now there are metal shingles and panels that imitate materials like slate tile wood shake and even asphalt. An asphalt shingle roof which costs between 3 50 and 7 per square foot installed. The metal can be in panels tiles or shingles but the look of a metal roof still can be jarring in a neighborhood full of asphalt shingles.

On the surface an asphalt shingle roof is the slim winner at 1 194 versus 1 267 for an abm panel metal roof does not include tax or labor. Metal roofing costs between 5 50 to 14 per square foot installed vs. Shingle questions i have. Asphalt shingles are quieter than metal roofing especially in heavy rain but some may think metal roofing is much louder than it actually is.

Standing seam means solar ready.